Why I Currently Avoid SEO Forums like the Plague
In SEO | 6 comments | permalink
I currently have a cold!
Not the most exciting way to start a blog post, nor the most interesting… but bear with me please.
I am not an expert when it comes to the common cold, I have had it many, many times, I know I don’t like it, but other than that.. I couldn’t claim to know the inner workings of a cold.
However, I have been fed enough information and advice in my lifetime to know a few facts about colds:
1) Going out with wet hair is a good way of catching a cold
2) You can get a cold more easily in cold weather
3) When you have a cold, drink lots of fluids, and especially hot drinks
4) Vitamin C can prevent a cold
All great cold based facts I am sure you will agree!
I am sure at some time you have heard all of the above, you probably hear these facts every time you get a cold, or go out into cold weather. “Put your scarf on, you will catch a cold” etc…
Well here is the kicker…. none of the above are true!
Not one of the above 4 “facts” are accurate, or true. They are myths bases on novels, myths, stories, and confused logic.
Going out with wet hair is not exactly smart, but a cold is an airborne virus, and is spread from person to person, it is not spread through the wind, and soaked into wet hair and then magically goes through your hair into your head.
Cold weather has no effect on getting a cold. It is true that people tend to get more colds in winter, but this is because they stay indoors more, and therefore are in close contact with people for longer periods.
Eating and drinking a lot will have no effect on curing your cold.
Recent studies also show that Vitamin C has little to no effect on curing a cold.
I got all this information from AOL, you can see the full set of cold myths for yourself here: cold myths
So what has this got to do with SEO forums? Well, SEO in general works in the same way… some information is created, it sounds fairly logical, and with zero concrete evidence, it becomes a fact and is spread by “experts” throughout the industry. If you go to any SEO forum you will see wild theories, crazy theories, and mad theories… but in all cases the author will be 100% certain they are true. It only takes a few other people to believe him/her and before you know it, it has become common practice.
This is why I now avoid SEO forums.
So how do we avoid this mis-information?
On the net, most people simply go by authority… but I have heard numerous doctors, teachers, and high profile magazines tell the above cold based myths, so my point is this: Don’t believe everything you read, especially on the net. If something sounds logical, or comes from an authority source, then it doesn’t mean it is true.
The single best way to overcome this is to try it yourself. If someone tells you that black is white, then test it. It may take an hour to test, but could save you hundreds of hours in the process.
We are in an industry where people have agendas and products they want to push, and they will sometimes say anything to get you to buy it.
Right, I am off to get some vitamin C and dry my wet hair ![]()
email this | tag this | digg this | trackback | comment RSS feed
Subscribe to my FEED for world domination
6 COMMENTS
Do You Feel the Buzz?
Dean Hunt puts the "buzz" in buzz marketing
..and the "viral" in viral diseases
Nice post… Think the analogy was a little bit weird
Can you give us some examples of what to look out for as absoloute web “bullshit” ?
Cheers
Tom
Hahaha You got your cold from that cold nosed wrinkle faced dog you should have named Buzz.
Just call it doggie karma or doggone karma
Tom - Weird is my favourite type, it means it will be remembered.
Chuck - I wanted to call it buzz, but ouldn’t work in Spain. They can’t physically do the Z sound.
It’s kind of “dialectical thinking” and I’ve been trying hard to apply it for the whole month:
Do not accept anything as an operating principle of your life (accept things, be open to new stuff but hole them to suspension) UNLESS you have a chance to TEST them and verify them by yourself.
It’s kind of thinking that is in the early ages, and Aristotel told that btw.
This is a very interesting perspective and a great analogy. I think the problem is that the very nature of SEO means that we’re stuck with hypothesising and theorising whilst never being able to accurately prove anything. Due to the nature of the internet, there are far too many variables involved in order to be able to test anything accurately and completely.
You’re absolutely right - the ambiguous nature of forums and the varying opinions and theories within them can cause a problem but I really don’t see any way of avoiding this. After spending a lot of time in the forums and speaking with different SEOs you will soon work out who you personally can and can’t trust. It’s a minefield, but that’s why we love it
To get high rankings in Yahoo and MSN is all about links? I can get ranked easier in Google with links,
but the other two I have no clue.